In recent years, Love Island USA has distinguished itself from the sea of tropical, horny reality dating shows, to become something of a longform sociological study in heterosexual dating. Going deeper than the mere interpersonal drama that seems to consume most of its contemporaries, the Peacock hit series offers lots of fodder for public commentary about modern dating, and especially how it intersects with misogyny, race, colorism, and class. In a way, Love Island USA is the heterosexual Hunger Games, the villa is the arena, and we, the viewers, are all peering into the panopticon each night, rooting for our victors and voting out our villains based largely on how they interact with and embody these systems — and of course, we also do pay attention to how genuine their connections seem. While the “boys versus girls” gendered divide between contestants has always been a tension point on Love Island, as it is in many reality dating shows, this season especially has sparked conversation about how much worse many of the men seem to be behaving toward the women they pursue. Indeed,here isn’t just one stand-out “villain” acting egregiously while their fellow islanders look on in horror, but rather a litany of offenses that viewers at home have been listing off. Let’s recap: Zach appeared to sow the seeds of doubt in men like Bryce and KC about their connections. He also omitted information about his Casa Amor connection being removed from the villa from his Kayda, saying he would have chosen her over Alannah, even though he had no option but to return to the villa alone. Corbin said he would be tossing Kenzie “out the window” after being presented with a bombshell he eventually coupled up with. KC called his initial connection, Aniya, “grandma” for not having sex with him after three weeks of him complementing her, in addition to making comments about whether both Aniya and his new connection Tierra “Titi” has earned his affection when choosing